Table 1 Emerging Dialogic Reading Domains: Cultural, Efferent, Aesthetic, Critical, and Dialogic
Domain | Stance | Example |
|---|---|---|
Cultural | Private aspect of meaning | Maria's evocation while reading Family pictures. She sings the song about the piñata. |
Efferent | Public aspect of meaning | Hiroki's and Jaewon are gaining information about Christopher Columbus's adventure story and Evert's new vocabulary. |
Aesthetic | Private aspect of meaning | Evert's and Maria's reading processes while reading I Hate English. |
Dialogic | Private and public aspect of meaning | Hiroki's and Jaewon's responses while reading Follow the Dream and Encounter: The two different depictions of Christopher Columbus drive from the authors' different intention. |
Critical | Private and public aspect of meaning | Jaewon's and Hiroki's exploration of the two versions of Christopher Columbus (Encounter and Follow the Dream). Hiroki said Christopher Columbus should not invade the Native Americans. |